Northeast Ohio Regional Sewer District
Outcome
Northeast Ohio Regional Sewer District agreed to pay $1.2 million civil penalty and implement approximately $3 billion in improvements by 2035, including seven storage tunnels and expansion of three wastewater treatment plants, capturing over 98% of wet weather flows serving Cleveland and 59 communities — one of the largest CSO consent decrees in Great Lakes history.
Details
Northeast Ohio Regional Sewer District — $3 Billion CSO Consent Decree Serving Cleveland Region (2010)
Outcome: Northeast Ohio Regional Sewer District agreed to pay a $1.2 million civil penalty (split equally between the United States and Ohio) and implement approximately $3 billion in infrastructure improvements by 2035, including construction of seven underground storage tunnels and expansion of three wastewater treatment plants, to capture and treat over 98% of wet weather flows entering the combined sewer system serving Cleveland and 59 surrounding communities.
The Northeast Ohio Regional Sewer District (NEORSD) provides wastewater collection and treatment services for the City of Cleveland and 59 surrounding communities in Cuyahoga, Medina, and Summit Counties, a service area of approximately 450,000 people. The district's combined sewer system, which dates to the 19th and early 20th centuries in Cleveland's older neighborhoods, discharged untreated combined sewage during wet weather events to Rocky River, Doan Brook, Mill Creek, Cuyahoga River, and ultimately Lake Erie, violating Clean Water Act permit conditions.
The settlement, announced December 22, 2010, required NEORSD to pay the $1.2 million civil penalty and implement a comprehensive 25-year remediation program. The program's infrastructure components include construction of seven large-diameter underground storage tunnels capable of capturing peak wet weather combined sewer flows for subsequent treatment, expansion of treatment capacity at three wastewater treatment plants, and implementation of green infrastructure projects as a supplemental approach to stormwater management. A household hazardous waste collection project was required as a Supplemental Environmental Project.
The settlement was subsequently modified to extend certain implementation deadlines to December 31, 2034, reflecting the scale of the construction program and the need to sequence tunnel construction without disrupting service. The final program is designed to achieve capture and treatment of over 98% of wet weather flows entering the combined system — among the highest CSO capture standards in any major consent decree.
Primary Source: Northeast Ohio Regional Sewer District Clean Water Act Settlement | US EPA
How Crucible Prevents This
A $3 billion, 25-year program serving Cleveland and 59 communities is one of the most complex municipal environmental compliance programs in the United States. Crucible's decision log preserving the engineering basis for each of the seven storage tunnels, the treatment plant expansion rationale, and the green infrastructure project selections — across a 59-jurisdiction service area — is essential institutional infrastructure for a program that must survive three to four complete cycles of district board governance and senior management. Session-init MEMORY ensuring incoming district CEOs and engineering directors are immediately briefed on outstanding consent decree obligations prevents the institutional drift that causes consent decree noncompliance.
Don't let this happen to your organization. See how Crucible works.
See How Crucible Works