Mahard Egg Farm, Inc.
Outcome
Mahard Egg Farm agreed to pay $1.9 million civil penalty — the largest ever assessed in a federal CAFO enforcement action at the time — and spend approximately $3.5 million on remedial measures at its Texas and Oklahoma facilities.
Details
Mahard Egg Farm, Inc. — Largest Federal CAFO Clean Water Act Penalty (2011)
Outcome: Mahard Egg Farm agreed to pay $1.9 million civil penalty — the largest ever assessed in a federal enforcement action against a concentrated animal feeding operation at the time — and spend approximately $3.5 million on remedial measures to bring its Texas and Oklahoma facilities into compliance.
Mahard Egg Farm, Inc., one of the larger egg production operations in Texas, operated concentrated animal feeding operations (CAFOs) at facilities in Texas and Oklahoma. Violations included unpermitted operation of CAFO facilities that required National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permits under the Clean Water Act, as well as permit violations at facilities where permits had been obtained. The operation's poultry waste management practices resulted in unauthorized discharges of manure, wastewater, and associated nutrient pollutants to waters of the United States.
The 2011 settlement required Mahard to pay the $1.9 million civil penalty — which established a new high-water mark for CAFO enforcement penalties at the federal level — and to invest approximately $3.5 million in facility improvements and remediation measures to achieve and maintain Clean Water Act compliance across both the Texas and Oklahoma operations. The record penalty amount signaled EPA's escalating enforcement posture toward large-scale egg and poultry operations that had historically operated without adequate NPDES permit coverage.
The case became a benchmark in CAFO enforcement, demonstrating that EPA was willing to impose substantial financial penalties on agricultural operations that had long treated water quality regulations as secondary concerns. The combination of penalty and remedial investment — totaling $5.4 million — created a significant financial deterrent for other large poultry operations operating without required permit coverage in the southern United States.
Primary Source: Mahard Egg Farm, Inc. Clean Water Act Settlement | US EPA
How Crucible Prevents This
Operating a large-scale egg production facility across state lines (Texas and Oklahoma) without proper NPDES permits is a compliance gap that a cross-facility permit tracking system would prevent. Crucible's compliance calendar maintaining permit status for each facility location, combined with session-init MEMORY that flags facilities operating without current permits, would have caught Mahard's permit violations at the outset rather than after years of unpermitted operation.
Don't let this happen to your organization. See how Crucible works.
See How Crucible Works