ImmediaDent of Indiana, LLC and Samson Dental Partners, LLC
Outcome
ImmediaDent of Indiana, LLC and Samson Dental Partners, LLC jointly paid $5.139 million to resolve False Claims Act allegations of Medicaid upcoding of tooth extractions and billing for medically unnecessary or unperformed deep cleanings at nine Indiana dental clinics.
Details
ImmediaDent of Indiana, LLC and Samson Dental Partners, LLC — Medicaid Upcoding and Unnecessary Procedures (2018)
Outcome: ImmediaDent of Indiana, LLC and Samson Dental Partners, LLC jointly paid $5.139 million to resolve False Claims Act allegations of Medicaid upcoding of tooth extractions and billing for medically unnecessary or unperformed deep cleanings at nine Indiana dental clinics.
ImmediaDent of Indiana, LLC operated nine dental care practices in Indiana. Samson Dental Partners, LLC, headquartered in Kansas, served as the dental service organization (DSO) managing the business operations of ImmediaDent's practices.
The United States and the State of Indiana alleged that between January 1, 2009, and September 30, 2013, the defendants submitted false claims to Indiana's Medicaid program through two schemes. First, they improperly billed simple tooth extractions as though they were surgical extractions — a more complex procedure that commands a higher reimbursement rate — a practice known as upcoding. Second, they improperly billed for Scale and Root Planing procedures (deep cleanings), which were either not medically necessary or were never performed on the patients billed.
The government further alleged that Samson Dental Partners violated Indiana's prohibition on the corporate practice of dentistry by improperly influencing ImmediaDent's clinical professionals and staff through production-based incentive structures — rewarding "productive" dentists with bonuses based on revenue generated, disciplining employees who did not meet production objectives, and directing clinical personnel in ways that compromised independent professional judgment.
The case originated with a qui tam whistleblower complaint filed February 20, 2013, by Dr. Jihaad Abdul-Majid in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Kentucky. The November 2018 settlement required the defendants to pay $3,400,271 to the United States and $1,782,729 to the State of Indiana. Dr. Abdul-Majid received $925,000 plus expenses and attorneys' fees from the federal share. Notably, this settlement made ImmediaDent and Samson the first entities placed on the OIG's new "High Risk — Heightened Scrutiny" monitoring list, subjecting them to enhanced oversight.
Primary Source: $5.1 Million Dollar Settlement Reached With Indiana Dental Firm To Resolve False Claims Allegations — DOJ Western District of Kentucky
How Crucible Prevents This
Crucible's billing compliance controls enforce procedure code accuracy at the point of documentation, flagging upcoding of simple extractions to surgical extractions through automated CDT code cross-referencing against procedure notes and radiographs. Mandatory clinical documentation requirements for each billed service would have prevented billing for deep cleanings lacking supporting periodontal charting. Crucible's separation of clinical and production metrics would have surfaced the incentive structure that pressured dentists to upcode — the core corporate-practice violation — through anomaly detection in billing-to-clinical-documentation ratios.
Don't let this happen to your organization. See how Crucible works.
See How Crucible Works