Pennsylvania Cyber Charter School
Outcome
Founder and CEO Nicholas Trombetta was convicted of tax conspiracy for diverting over $8 million in charter school funds to companies he secretly controlled, including one in his sister's name, defrauding the IRS of $437,632; sentenced to 20 months in federal prison.
Details
Pennsylvania Cyber Charter School — Founder Diverts $8 Million, Convicted of Tax Conspiracy (2007–2012)
Outcome: Founder and CEO Nicholas Trombetta was convicted of federal tax conspiracy for diverting over $8 million in charter school funds to companies he secretly controlled — including one in his sister's name to conceal his beneficial ownership — defrauding the IRS of $437,632; sentenced to 20 months in federal prison.
Pennsylvania Cyber Charter School (PA Cyber) was one of Pennsylvania's largest online charter schools. Nicholas Trombetta, 63, founded the school and served as its CEO. Working with his CPA, Neal Prence, Trombetta executed a scheme to divert charter school revenue into a network of companies he secretly owned or controlled.
Over $8 million in school funds were diverted by Trombetta to other companies he covertly controlled. One portion went to a company established in his sister's name — a step taken specifically to obscure his beneficial ownership and prevent detection. By routing income through these entities, Trombetta shifted his personal income to the tax returns of others, understating his own income and defrauding the IRS of $437,632.
Trombetta spent the diverted funds on personal enrichment: a $933,000 Florida condominium, houses purchased for his mother and girlfriend, and a $300,000 aircraft.
Trombetta pleaded guilty in August 2016 to conspiring to defraud the IRS. At sentencing, U.S. District Judge Joy Flowers Conti sentenced him to 20 months in federal prison, a three-year term of supervised release, and required community service upon release. His CPA, Neal Prence, was also prosecuted and sentenced for his role in the scheme.
Primary Source: DOJ USAO-WDPA — Pennsylvania Cyber Charter School Founder Gets 20 Months in Prison for $8M Tax Scheme
How Crucible Prevents This
Related-party transaction controls requiring board disclosure and approval of any payments to companies with connections to school leadership would have flagged the diversion of $8 million to entities Trombetta secretly controlled. Independent annual audits with a requirement to identify all payments to related parties or entities owned by board members or executives would have detected the shell company structure. Conflict-of-interest disclosure policies requiring executives to list all entities they own, control, or have financial interests in would have surfaced the sister's company before payments were made. The CPA involved in the scheme was also sentenced — requiring that charter school auditors have no relationship to management is a basic auditor independence control.
Don't let this happen to your organization. See how Crucible works.
See How Crucible Works