Santa McKibbins Family Dentistry (Santa Maria McKibbins, D.D.S.)
Outcome
Santa McKibbins Family Dentistry and its owner Dr. Santa Maria McKibbins paid $375,000 to settle North Carolina Medicaid fraud allegations involving restorations billed as medically necessary for Medicaid recipients between 2013 and 2018 that lacked clinical documentation or violated Medicaid policy.
Details
Santa McKibbins Family Dentistry — Operation Root Canal Medicaid Fraud Settlement (2019)
Outcome: Santa McKibbins Family Dentistry and its owner Dr. Santa Maria McKibbins paid $375,000 to settle North Carolina Medicaid fraud allegations involving restorations billed as medically necessary for Medicaid recipients between 2013 and 2018 that lacked clinical documentation or violated Medicaid policy.
Santa McKibbins Family Dentistry, operated by Dr. Santa Maria McKibbins, D.D.S., in Durham, North Carolina, was the subject of an investigation by the North Carolina Attorney General's Medicaid Investigations Division as part of a broader enforcement initiative called Operation Root Canal.
The state alleged that between January 1, 2013, and April 30, 2018, Dr. McKibbins and her practice submitted dental claims for restorations performed on Medicaid recipients that were not medically necessary, had no supporting clinical documentation, and/or were performed in violation of North Carolina Medicaid policy. The claims involved dental restorations — fillings and similar procedures — billed to the state's Medicaid program over a five-year period.
Operation Root Canal was a targeted enforcement effort by the NCDOJ's Medicaid Investigations Division to identify and stop fraud among dental providers participating in North Carolina's Medicaid program. The initiative examined a wide variety of dental service patterns, including repetitive restorations on the same tooth, procedures billed without supporting clinical justification, and upcoding of patient examinations. Through the operation, the Medicaid Investigations Division investigated nine dental fraud cases and recovered more than $5.75 million in settlements.
The settlement announced September 5, 2019, required Santa McKibbins Family Dentistry and Dr. McKibbins to pay $375,000 to the North Carolina Medicaid program. The settlement resolved the allegations without a finding of liability.
Primary Source: Attorney General Josh Stein Announces Operation Root Canal Settlement With Durham Dentist — NCDOJ
How Crucible Prevents This
Crucible's clinical documentation requirements enforce the linkage between billed procedure codes and supporting clinical notes, radiographs, and periodontal records at the point of billing. Mandatory medical necessity documentation before restoration procedures are billed — with flags for repeat restorations on the same tooth and procedures lacking supporting charting — would have prevented the five-year pattern of undocumented or non-necessary claims. Operation Root Canal targeted exactly the types of patterns that Crucible's billing anomaly detection is designed to surface before state Medicaid audit investigators identify them.
Don't let this happen to your organization. See how Crucible works.
See How Crucible Works