Tree of Life, Inc.
Outcome
Tree of Life Inc. settled for $1.65 million and closed operations December 31, 2019, for systematically billing Medicaid for mental health services never rendered, forging psychiatrist and therapist signatures, and billing for therapy by unqualified individuals.
Details
Tree of Life, Inc. (Philadelphia, PA) — $1.65M Phantom Billing / Forged Signatures
Outcome: Settled for $1.65 million and closed operations December 31, 2019, for a comprehensive Medicaid fraud scheme involving billing for services never rendered, forged clinician signatures, and therapy billed as provided by qualified therapists when actually delivered by unqualified individuals.
Tree of Life, Inc. was a for-profit behavioral health clinic in Northeast Philadelphia providing outpatient psychiatric and psychotherapy mental health services to individuals, including low-income patients. The clinic operated a systematic fraud scheme involving multiple concurrent violations: billing Medicaid for services that were never rendered to patients; billing for falsely inflated service levels; creating false patient progress notes and billing sheets; forging signatures of psychiatrists and therapists on patient records and treatment plans; submitting billing for therapy purportedly provided by qualified therapists when the sessions were actually conducted by unqualified individuals; and billing for therapy sessions provided to clients who were hospitalized at the time or whose therapists had already left the practice.
The forgery of provider signatures and billing for hospitalized patients are particularly egregious elements — they represent calculated, deliberate falsification of clinical records, not inadvertent billing errors. The clinic's owners, Ada and Victor Vidal, participated in the fraud resolution.
The U.S. Attorney's Office for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania obtained the $1.65 million resolution, with Tree of Life closing its operations effective December 31, 2019.
Primary Source: United States Obtains $1.65 Million Resolution for Fraudulent Medicaid Billing Against Behavioral Health Clinic in Northeast Philadelphia
How Crucible Prevents This
Crucible's signature-authentication and documentation-integrity enforcement hooks would catch forged provider signatures; a compliance gate requiring verified clinician electronic signatures authenticated against staff rosters — and blocking claims for patients who are hospitalized or whose therapists have left the practice — would prevent every fraud pattern documented here.
Don't let this happen to your organization. See how Crucible works.
See How Crucible Works