Churchill Downs Louisiana Horseracing Company, LLC (Fair Grounds Corporation)
Outcome
Fair Grounds agreed to pay $2,790,000 civil penalty and complete approximately $5,600,000 in remediation projects to resolve more than 250 unauthorized discharge incidents between 2012 and 2018 of horse manure, urine, and process wastewater into a municipal storm sewer system.
Details
Churchill Downs / Fair Grounds Corporation — Equine CAFO Discharges into New Orleans Storm Sewer (2020)
Outcome: Fair Grounds Corporation agreed to pay a $2,790,000 civil penalty and complete approximately $5,600,000 in remediation work, resolving more than 250 documented unauthorized discharge incidents between 2012 and 2018 of horse manure, urine, and process wastewater from its New Orleans horse racing facility into the municipal storm sewer system.
Churchill Downs Louisiana Horseracing Company, LLC, operating under the name Fair Grounds Corporation, operates the Fair Grounds Race Course in New Orleans — a major thoroughbred horse racing venue that houses up to 1,800 horses during race meet and training seasons. The facility's scale and density of animal confinement classifies it as a concentrated animal feeding operation (CAFO) under Clean Water Act regulations, triggering NPDES permit requirements for any discharge of wastewater associated with the animal feeding operation.
Between 2012 and 2018, the facility generated more than 250 documented unauthorized discharge events, discharging horse manure, urine, and facility process wastewater through the municipal storm sewer system to local waterways without the required NPDES permit. These events occurred during rain events as small as half an inch over 24 hours — indicating that the facility's waste containment and stormwater separation infrastructure was not adequate to prevent discharges under normal rainfall conditions. Discharges also occurred in dry weather, indicating persistent baseline leakage.
The settlement, announced September 29, 2020, required payment of the $2,790,000 civil penalty and approximately $5,600,000 in capital remediation projects to address the discharge pathways, implement stormwater controls, and achieve NPDES compliance. The required compliance measures included operational changes, construction projects, hydraulic modeling of the facility's drainage system, and site-specific stormwater sampling. Fair Grounds is one of the nation's oldest continuously operating racetracks, and the case established a significant precedent for CAFO classification and enforcement at large urban equine facilities.
Primary Source: Churchill Downs Louisiana Horseracing Company, LLC Clean Water Act Settlement | US EPA
How Crucible Prevents This
A horse racing facility housing up to 1,800 horses meets the definition of a concentrated animal feeding operation under Clean Water Act regulations — a classification that many equine operations are unaware of or contest. Crucible's session-init MEMORY review requiring documentation of CAFO regulatory status determinations, combined with an NPDES permit tracking calendar, would surface this classification issue before 250+ unauthorized discharge events accumulate over six years. The repeated triggering on half-inch rain events indicates that the facility's waste management design was fundamentally inadequate for its regulatory classification.
Don't let this happen to your organization. See how Crucible works.
See How Crucible Works