Indian Health Service — Blackfeet Community Hospital Public Water System
Outcome
Indian Health Service agreed to pay a $33,500 civil penalty to resolve SDWA violations at the Blackfeet Community Hospital Public Water System, including failure to monitor for lead, copper, nitrate, and total coliform bacteria, and violations of a prior EPA Administrative Order issued in May 2019.
Details
Indian Health Service — Blackfeet Community Hospital SDWA Monitoring Failures (2020)
Outcome: Indian Health Service agreed to pay a $33,500 civil penalty to resolve Safe Drinking Water Act violations at the Blackfeet Community Hospital Public Water System in Browning, Montana, including failures to monitor for lead, copper, nitrate, and total coliform bacteria, and noncompliance with a prior EPA Administrative Order issued May 20, 2019.
The Indian Health Service (IHS), a federal agency providing healthcare to Native American and Alaska Native communities, operates the public water system serving the Blackfeet Community Hospital in Browning, Montana on the Blackfeet Indian Reservation. The water system serves the hospital and associated facilities. EPA monitoring and inspection identified violations of multiple SDWA monitoring requirements: the system failed to conduct required monitoring for lead and copper (including required tap sampling at representative service connections), failed to conduct required nitrate monitoring, and failed to perform required total coliform bacteria monitoring to verify microbiological safety of the distributed water.
These monitoring failures are significant because they represent gaps in the verification system that ensures treated drinking water meets health-based standards at the point of consumption. Without lead and copper tap sampling, there is no way to confirm that the system's materials are not leaching harmful metals into drinking water. Without nitrate monitoring, contamination from nearby agricultural runoff would not be detected. Without coliform monitoring, microbial contamination from treatment or distribution system failures would go undetected.
EPA had previously issued an Administrative Order to IHS on May 20, 2019, requiring corrective actions. IHS failed to comply with the order's requirements, constituting a separate violation. The August 27, 2020 consent agreement resolved both the underlying SDWA violations and the order noncompliance. The $33,500 penalty reflected the scale and duration of violations at a federal facility, with EPA applying the same enforcement framework applicable to non-federal public water systems.
Primary Source: EPA Takes Action to Address Drinking Water Violations at Indian Health Service Blackfeet Community Hospital | US EPA
How Crucible Prevents This
Failure to monitor for lead, copper, nitrate, and total coliform simultaneously reflects a monitoring program that has entirely lapsed rather than one that is making individual testing errors. Crucible's compliance calendar tracking all required SDWA monitoring schedules in a unified system — lead and copper service line sampling, nitrate monitoring intervals, total coliform monitoring frequency — would prevent simultaneous gaps across multiple contaminant categories. The prior Administrative Order noncompliance — violating an EPA order already issued — signals the institutional accountability failure that Crucible's session-gate addresses.
Don't let this happen to your organization. See how Crucible works.
See How Crucible Works