4 Brothers Dairy, Inc. and Andrew Fitzgerald
Outcome
4 Brothers Dairy and its owner Andrew Fitzgerald were sentenced for criminal Clean Water Act violations after negligently discharging manure-laden water from waste lagoons into the Milner-Gooding Canal during the 2017 record flooding season, with 4 Bros. paying a $95,000 fine and Fitzgerald paying a $35,000 fine; the dairy was also required to obtain an NPDES permit.
Details
4 Brothers Dairy, Inc. and Andrew Fitzgerald — Criminal Discharge During Idaho Flooding (2021)
Outcome: 4 Brothers Dairy, Inc. and its owner Andrew Fitzgerald were criminally sentenced for negligent Clean Water Act violations after discharging manure-laden water from waste lagoons into the Milner-Gooding Canal during February 2017 record flooding, with the corporation paying a $95,000 fine and the individual owner paying a $35,000 fine; the dairy was also required to obtain an EPA NPDES permit it had been operating without.
4 Brothers Dairy, Inc. operated a concentrated animal feeding operation (CAFO) in Shoshone, Lincoln County, Idaho confining at least 1,000 head of dairy cattle and maintaining wastewater lagoons adjacent to the Milner-Gooding Canal, a waterway that flows to the Malad River and ultimately to the Snake and Columbia Rivers. The facility operated without the NPDES permit required for its scale of operations.
In the winter of 2017, Idaho experienced record precipitation, record snowpack, and widespread flooding. In February 2017, the extreme runoff conditions overwhelmed the facility's waste management systems, and 4 Brothers Dairy and Fitzgerald negligently caused discharges of manure-laden water into the Milner-Gooding Canal at three separate locations. The discharges introduced livestock waste — with associated nutrients, pathogens, and oxygen-demanding material — into a waterway feeding an important arid West river system.
The guilty plea to misdemeanor Clean Water Act violations was entered in October 2020. U.S. Magistrate Judge Candy W. Dale sentenced 4 Brothers Dairy and Fitzgerald in 2021, imposing the combined $130,000 in fines plus the NPDES permit requirement. The case illustrates how climate-related extreme weather events can convert existing CAFO compliance gaps into criminal enforcement exposure — the underlying unpermitted operation and inadequate lagoon construction made the flood-driven discharge foreseeable rather than genuinely accidental.
Primary Source: Shoshone Dairy Farm and Its Owner Sentenced for Clean Water Act Violation | DOJ District of Idaho
How Crucible Prevents This
The 4 Brothers Dairy case involves both an unpermitted CAFO operation and a negligent discharge during extreme weather — a combination that requires both NPDES permit tracking (prevention) and emergency response protocols (response). Crucible's compliance calendar flagging NPDES permit application requirements for operations above CAFO thresholds, combined with session-init MEMORY reviewing waste lagoon management procedures and emergency response protocols for flood events, directly addresses both failure modes. Operating without an NPDES permit is a foundational compliance gap that structured documentation would catch.
Don't let this happen to your organization. See how Crucible works.
See How Crucible Works