Gethsemane Cemetery (City of Detroit / Necaba Management Group Inc.)
Outcome
A June 2021 class action lawsuit alleged that Gethsemane Cemetery sold burial plots that already contained remains, resulting in multiple bodies buried in single plots and families misled about their loved ones' burial locations; FBI and Detroit Police conducted exhumations, but the city was ultimately granted sovereign immunity and the cemetery contractor entered bankruptcy, with no criminal charges or financial accountability imposed.
Details
Gethsemane Cemetery (City of Detroit) — Double Burial and Plot Oversale (2015–2021)
Outcome: A class action lawsuit in June 2021 alleged systematic double-burial of remains in already-occupied plots at Detroit's Gethsemane Cemetery; FBI and Detroit Police conducted exhumations, but the city was granted sovereign immunity and the cemetery's management contractor entered bankruptcy, resulting in no criminal charges and no financial accountability for affected families.
Background
Gethsemane Cemetery is a historic municipal cemetery in Detroit, Michigan, originally dedicated in 1909 by two Evangelical Lutheran churches and later operated by the City of Detroit through its Parks and Recreation Department. Between approximately March 2015 and May 2020, the city contracted cemetery management operations to private entities, including Necaba Management Group Inc. (Southfield, Michigan) and later Enduring Memories Cemetery Management Company.
Under the private management contract, Necaba's principal Sam Tocco admitted in a video deposition that his company sold between 2,000 and 3,000 burials at Gethsemane Cemetery between March 2015 and May 2020.
The Violations
As Gethsemane approached the limits of its burial space, the management contractor continued selling burial plots without maintaining accurate records of which plots were already occupied. The class action complaint alleged:
- Double-sold burial plots: Families paid for plots that already contained the remains of other individuals
- Multiple bodies in single plots: Investigation found individual plots containing the remains of four or more individuals
- Missing remains: At least one family reported that their family member's headstone was present but the burial plot below contained the bodies of four other individuals instead of their relative
- Recordkeeping failure: Records were not maintained that would allow correlation between sold plots and actual burials
- Improper disinterment: Remains were moved or disturbed without family consent or legal authority
Investigation
Detroit Police and the local FBI field office initiated an investigation into the complaints and conducted exhumations at the cemetery to locate missing remains. The investigation confirmed multiple instances of bodies buried in already-occupied plots.
Legal Outcomes
A class action lawsuit filed in June 2021 named the City of Detroit, New Calvary Baptist Church (which had a historical relationship with the cemetery), Necaba Management Group Inc., and Enduring Memories Cemetery Management Company.
The litigation ultimately failed to produce financial accountability:
- A Wayne County judge granted sovereign immunity to the City of Detroit
- The private cemetery management contractor(s) entered bankruptcy protection, precluding civil recovery
- No criminal charges were ever filed against any individual or entity
Regulatory Gap
Michigan LARA (Department of Licensing and Regulatory Affairs), which regulates private cemeteries, had no jurisdiction over Gethsemane because it is a city-owned municipal cemetery. The regulatory gap between municipal ownership and private management left no state oversight body with authority to regulate the cemetery's day-to-day operations.
Primary Source: Detroit News — Lawsuit targets Detroit, church, companies in burial plot mixups at Gethsemane Cemetery (June 9, 2021)
How Crucible Prevents This
Gethsemane is a city-owned cemetery contracted to a private management company — a governance structure where accountability falls between municipal sovereign immunity and private contractor liability, allowing both parties to evade responsibility when misconduct occurs. A compliance protocol for such public-private cemetery arrangements must include: independent annual reconciliation of burial records against physical plot inventory, third-party contractor performance auditing with results reported to city council, and clear contractual assignment of liability for burial errors. The outcome here — no criminal charges, no financial accountability — demonstrates what happens when oversight structures are absent. Michigan LARA had no jurisdiction over a city-owned cemetery, leaving a complete regulatory gap.
Don't let this happen to your organization. See how Crucible works.
See How Crucible Works