Atlantic Union Bank
Outcome
The CFPB ordered Atlantic Union Bank to pay $6.2 million in December 2023 — $5 million in consumer refunds plus a $1.2 million civil penalty — for deceiving customers into signing up for overdraft coverage through flawed in-branch opt-in processes and misleading telephone enrollment practices during 2017–2020.
Details
Atlantic Union Bank — CFPB $6.2 Million Overdraft Opt-In Deception Penalty (2023)
Outcome: The CFPB ordered Atlantic Union Bank, a regional bank headquartered in Richmond, Virginia, to pay $6.2 million in December 2023 — $5 million in consumer refunds for overdraft fees charged and $1.2 million in civil penalties — for violating Regulation E's opt-in requirements and engaging in deceptive overdraft enrollment practices from 2017 through 2020.
Atlantic Union Bank violated the Electronic Fund Transfer Act's opt-in requirements governing overdraft services through two distinct enrollment channels. In its in-branch account opening process, bank employees requested that new customers provide their overdraft enrollment decision orally before providing the customers with an adequate written notice describing the overdraft service's costs and terms — a direct violation of Regulation E's requirement that the written notice be provided and acknowledged before enrollment occurs.
The telephone enrollment violations were broader. When customers enrolled in overdraft coverage over the phone, Atlantic Union Bank employees consistently failed to clearly explain which transaction types were actually covered by the service, made misleading statements about the terms and conditions, and in many calls omitted key disclosures about the cost of the service and the fact that consumers could incur substantial overdraft fees for every individual transaction. Customers enrolled through these calls had reason to believe they were consenting to a service materially different from what was actually being sold to them.
The December 7, 2023 CFPB consent order required Atlantic Union Bank to provide $5 million in refunds to affected consumers who had been charged overdraft fees resulting from these flawed enrollment practices, and to pay a $1.2 million civil money penalty to the CFPB's victims relief fund. The action reflected the CFPB's consistent post-2021 focus on overdraft fee practices, treating deceptive enrollment methods as a distinct consumer harm from the fee amounts themselves.
Primary Source: CFPB Enforcement Action — Atlantic Union Bank (December 7, 2023)
How Crucible Prevents This
Crucible's instinct-observer hook would detect patterns of customer complaints about unexpected overdraft fees, especially correlated with in-branch account openings. The pre-tool-check hook would require documented Regulation E opt-in procedure review before any changes to overdraft enrollment workflows. The quality-gate would flag telephone enrollment scripts that omit required fee disclosures.
Don't let this happen to your organization. See how Crucible works.
See How Crucible Works