Dexter Prescription Center a/k/a Dexter Pharmacy

Buffalo, NY 2019--2023 Independent Pharmacies
DOJ DEA Controlled Substance Recordkeeping Misbilling Federal Programs False Claims
Penalty
$141,727

Outcome

Dexter Prescription Center settled for $141,727 for violating Controlled Substances Act record keeping requirements and overcharging federal healthcare programs.

Details

Dexter Pharmacy (Buffalo, NY) — DEA Recordkeeping Violations / Misbilling

Outcome: Settled for $141,727 for violating Controlled Substances Act recordkeeping requirements and billing federal healthcare programs in excess of appropriate amounts.

Dexter Prescription Center, doing business as Dexter Pharmacy in Buffalo, New York, violated the record-keeping requirements of the Controlled Substances Act and submitted bills to federal healthcare programs for amounts that exceeded proper reimbursement rates. The dual nature of the violation — regulatory noncompliance with DEA requirements combined with billing overcharges — suggests a pharmacy with systemic compliance gaps across multiple program requirements.

The U.S. Attorney's Office for the Western District of New York pursued both criminal and civil enforcement actions, resulting in a $141,727 settlement announced August 23, 2024.

Primary Source: Buffalo Pharmacy Pays More Than $140,000 To Settle Record Keeping And Misbilling Allegations

How Crucible Prevents This

Crucible's DEA record-keeping compliance hooks and billing-accuracy controls would catch both violations; automated reconciliation of CSA dispense logs against DEA-required records, combined with payer rate verification before submission, would prevent record-keeping gaps and misbilling simultaneously.

Source: Buffalo Pharmacy Pays More Than $140,000 To Settle Record Keeping And Misbilling Allegations

Don't let this happen to your organization. See how Crucible works.

See How Crucible Works