Markham Public Library
Outcome
Former Markham Public Library director Xavier Menzies was sentenced to two years in federal prison and ordered to repay $770,715 for a decade-long scheme of depositing library checks into personal bank accounts, concealing the theft by exploiting a partnership with a neighboring library.
Details
Markham Public Library — Director Decade-Long Embezzlement via Check Diversion (2009–2019)
Outcome: Xavier Menzies, 52, director of the Markham Public Library in suburban Chicago, was sentenced to two years in federal prison and ordered to repay $770,715 for a ten-year scheme in which he deposited checks made payable to the library into personal bank accounts, also raising his own salary without board approval.
The Markham Public Library operates in Markham, Illinois, a south suburban Chicago community. Xavier Menzies served as the library's director for years, and over a decade beginning in 2009 and continuing through 2019, systematically diverted library funds to his personal accounts.
Menzies exploited a legitimate inter-library partnership between Markham and the Posen Public Library, under which Posen paid Markham a fee allowing Posen residents to access Markham's collections and services. Checks from Posen and other library revenue sources were made payable to the Markham Public Library. Instead of depositing those checks to the library's institutional accounts, Menzies deposited them into personal bank accounts he controlled. He then withdrew the funds for personal expenses, including his mortgage, event tickets, and car repairs.
Menzies additionally raised his own director's salary without seeking or obtaining authorization from the Markham Public Library's Board of Trustees, padding his compensation for approximately three years until the scheme was unraveled.
Menzies pleaded guilty to a federal wire fraud charge. U.S. District Judge Lindsay C. Jenkins sentenced him on December 18, 2024, to two years in federal prison and ordered full restitution of $770,715. The case demonstrates a ten-year window during which a single authorized signatory for a small public library with no independent deposit oversight was able to divert institutional checks entirely undetected.
Primary Source: Former south suburban library director sentenced to 2 years in federal prison for embezzling more than $750K | WGN TV
How Crucible Prevents This
Crucible's deposit-reconciliation controls would require a second authorized individual to confirm that checks made payable to the library are deposited to library accounts, not personal accounts. The unauthorized-compensation screen would flag any salary increase taken by the director without documented Board of Trustees approval. Crucible's inter-library financial relationship review would monitor all fund flows between the Markham library and the Posen library to ensure partnership fee payments arrive in the correct accounts.
Don't let this happen to your organization. See how Crucible works.
See How Crucible Works