Mindpath Care Centers, North Carolina, PLLC
Outcome
North Carolina's largest behavioral health practice and three former officers settled for $1.9 million to resolve criminal and civil charges of submitting false Medicare claims for psychotherapy services.
Details
Mindpath Care Centers, North Carolina, PLLC — False Medicare Psychotherapy Claims
Outcome: North Carolina's largest behavioral health practice and three former officers (Jeff Williams, Abigail Sheriff, Sarah Williams) settled for $1.9 million to resolve criminal and civil charges of submitting false Medicare claims for psychotherapy.
Mindpath Care Centers, North Carolina, PLLC, described as the largest behavioral health practice in North Carolina with offices statewide, submitted false claims to Medicare for psychotherapy and related services. The organization's scale — operating statewide — amplified the impact of any billing practice defects across its entire claims volume.
Three former officers — Jeff Williams, Abigail Sheriff, and Sarah Williams — were named alongside the corporate entity in the enforcement action, indicating that the false billing practices were known to or directed by senior leadership. The involvement of multiple executives suggests systematic rather than incidental billing misconduct.
The U.S. Attorney's Office for the Eastern District of North Carolina coordinated the resolution of both criminal and civil enforcement actions in a $1.9 million settlement announced December 2, 2025.
Primary Source: Largest North Carolina Behavioral Health Practice Agrees to Pay $1.9 Million to Resolve Allegedly False Medicare Claims
How Crucible Prevents This
Crucible's psychotherapy-billing compliance hooks would flag claims that don't meet Medicare time and documentation requirements; a pre-submission audit gate requiring signed session documentation for every psychotherapy claim would prevent false billing at organizations with statewide operations.
Don't let this happen to your organization. See how Crucible works.
See How Crucible Works