Project Social Care Head Start Inc. (PSCHS)
Outcome
Shadow executive director Arie Rangott was sentenced to 27 months in federal prison for conspiring to defraud the federal Head Start program and obstruct an HHS investigation, after he and co-conspirators used the nonprofit's Head Start grant funding to enrich for-profit companies they secretly controlled through undisclosed self-dealing.
Details
Project Social Care Head Start Inc. (New York City) — Shadow Executive Head Start Grant Fraud (2021–2023)
Outcome: Arie Rangott, the shadow executive director of Project Social Care Head Start Inc., was sentenced to 27 months in federal prison for conspiring to defraud the federal Head Start program and obstruct an HHS Office of Inspector General investigation, after he and co-conspirators used Head Start grant funds to secretly enrich for-profit companies they controlled through undisclosed self-dealing contracts.
Project Social Care Head Start Inc. (PSCHS) operated in the New York City area and annually received millions of dollars in HHS grant funding designated exclusively for the Head Start program serving low-income preschool children. PSCHS was formally governed by an independent board of directors, but Arie Rangott functioned as the organization's shadow executive director — exercising actual operational control without holding the formal title.
According to the government, Rangott and his co-conspirators used their control over PSCHS to direct Head Start grant funding to for-profit companies owned by co-conspirators through undisclosed self-dealing transactions. The impermissible payments enriched the co-conspirators at the expense of the children and families the Head Start program was meant to serve.
When HHS raised concerns about self-dealing at PSCHS in December 2021, Rangott and others submitted misleading reports to HHS denying any wrongdoing and concealing the self-dealing. When HHS's Office of the Inspector General launched a formal investigation in August 2022, Rangott and co-conspirators continued to obstruct the investigation.
Co-conspirators Martin Handler was sentenced to 58 months in prison in October 2024, and Isidore Handler was sentenced to 18 months in December 2024. Rangott was sentenced to 27 months in federal prison. The Southern District of New York prosecuted the case, announced by Acting U.S. Attorney Matthew Podolsky.
How Crucible Prevents This
Crucible's vendor-self-dealing detection controls would require all grant recipients to disclose and obtain prior approval for any transaction with a company connected to an officer, director, or shadow executive. The nominal-board oversight screen would flag governance structures where a "shadow executive" exercises actual control without formal fiduciary accountability. Crucible's federal-grant compliance workflow would require annual independent financial audits submitted directly to HHS, making it impossible to submit misleading compliance reports without independent verification.
Don't let this happen to your organization. See how Crucible works.
See How Crucible Works